More CFB realignment: Army to AAC

DISCLAIMER: Forum topics may not have been written or edited by The Key Play staff.

Comments

I'd love to see a back-to-back Army-Navy contest one day.

Maybe it's because Army isn't in my vicinity, and maybe it's because they are lower level FBS and don't move the needle much, but darnit it seems like these level of teams can maneuver in the landscape easily with "football only" moves that truly makes me jealous for all the other sports at VT.

To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
@VTnerf on insta, @BuryHokie on twitter, #ThanksFrank

I'm not sure it's something to be jealous of; a lot of these teams/conferences do it out of necessity. Some random thoughts about this:

  • Being independent in football makes it really hard to find 12 games per year
  • Being independent in football makes it really hard to find a home for your other sports
  • Being in a single league for all sports allows you save money (per athlete) when it comes to traveling (eg; Softball, Gymnastics, and Tennis can all play at the same school in the same weekend, which means you can charter a single plane instead of having 2 teams fly commercial to different locations while one team buses).
  • A lot of these conferences are adding teams as 'football only' members because otherwise the conference would fall apart
  • You'll notice that none of the top conferences have 'football only' members
  • VT used to be a football only member of the Big East(?) and it was not a desirable situation

To your second point. All you have to do is 1. offer to play 4-6 football games of your choosing each year with conference teams. 2. Add your perceived weight to the camping world bowl negotiations. If you do those 2 simple things, you can find arguably the best olympic conference for your other teams.

I just wish that football would form their own conferences. That money can still benefit the remaining sports. But there is ZERO reason for volleyball or wrestling form BC to travel to Miami or now Cal for a match. These sports should be regional. Football can have their own meg-conferences and travel away. Dragging the rest of the sports along with them is silly.

To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
@VTnerf on insta, @BuryHokie on twitter, #ThanksFrank

I agree, and I think it's inevitable tbh

So random question? Do Army, Navy and Air Force have to deal with Title IX scholarships for sports? Historically I think attendance at those schools is about 90% male. Do they have any actual scholarship money for sports or is it covered by the Army, Navy, or Air Force due to their service requirements?

Students, instructors, and other employees at federal service academies are not covered by Title IX.

To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
@VTnerf on insta, @BuryHokie on twitter, #ThanksFrank

They don't have to deal with scholarships at all for sports, since every student at the academies are on full scholarships.

Additionally, all students are required to participate in athletics.

I actually did not know that. What if you are in good shape (well you have to be to get in anyway) but have never really played a sport? Do they just find a spot on the track team or something? I'm sure most appointees most likely participated in a team sport of some kind in high school so probably not a big issue to find something for them to do.

Oh God, I would be terrible at this. I have no idea what direction is which once I enter a building, I lived in SLC for 3 months and never figured it out, and I frequently turn out of parking lots the wrong direction. Something is definitely wrong with my hippocampus.

hippocampuscompass

FTFY

Onward and upward

Where'd that dad joke thread go anyways

(add if applicable) /s

Don't they all have to do that as part of the Army training anyway?

Deposit whiskey, receive wisdom.

Pretty sure they count club sports and intramurals. Even at the Chesapeake University of Naval Technology, not everyone is an athlete

You'll notice that none of the top conferences have 'football only' members

I may be wrong here, but didn't notre dame join the ACC as football only, at least initially? I'm not sure if they are in the ACC for different sports now, but then maybe you aren't counting the ACC as one of the "top conferences."

Ut Prosim Ad Dei Gloriam

No- never joined for football initially. They only played "acc" football during covid

Nope, ND is everything but football. The opposite of football only.

It's hard to remain an independent in college sports, unless you're Notre Dame.

They tried this once with Conference USA and could not compete. Good luck Army.

So theoretically they could end up playing three times in a season then? Unless the conference never schedules them as part of round-Robin scheduling.

Rob Peterson
VTCC
Charlie/Hotel Company
Class of 1999

In-season game..
Annual Army-Navy Game...
AAC Conference championship...

Why can't the annual Army-Navy game become a required end-of-season rivalry game in conference play? Is it because the AAC only does round-robin?

More likely because their TV revenues are a lot higher for that weekend because there is a lot less competition.

Because the Army v Navy game is so late in the schedule. American Conference regular season has to be over and participants in Championship game decided

Given that, couldn't, theoretically, they play regular season, then the conf championship game, then the annual match, in that order?

To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
@VTnerf on insta, @BuryHokie on twitter, #ThanksFrank

and I think that theoretical number is 4
- Annual conference game
- Annual Army-Navy
- Conference championship
- CFP matchup, which would be an insanely improbable occurrence

At first I thought this said 'Army to the ACC' and I thought to myself "yeah.... that tracks"

"When I was growing up, Virginia Tech was a school that was kicking ass and taking names, and it's time we get back to that" - James Franklin

It would have made more geographic sense than the last few additions...