'26 composite 4* WR Carnell Warren commits to the Hokies

https://www.on3.com/db/carnell-warren-236207/
https://247sports.com/player/carnell-warren-46142200/

Forums: 
DISCLAIMER: Forum topics may not have been written or edited by The Key Play staff.

Comments

Helluva way to lead off the '26 class.

Welcome Home, Carnell

Solid start. Build some more 4* around them and keep them on board.

(add if applicable) /s

Fuck yeah

I want to be happy but with his size and ranking why not Clemson or USCe? I am used to talent in VA leaving for other schools but not big talent in other states leaving for VT, if they do, they rarely stay committed through signing day.

FIRST DOWN, HOKIES!

Hopefully he talks to Hiter and Iheancho at the UA game

Outside it's night time, but inside it's LeDay

Excellent. Now we need a QB that can get the ball to him ... and an OL that gives the QB time to get the ball to him.

Recovering scientist working in business consulting

Pop should be pretty experienced by then.

"Yes I am going to have favorites. My favorites are high production and low maintenance players, coaches, and staff." - JMFF

i like what pop has got

i love davi, i think he is legit the answer

I been here since day 0.

Interesting...I don't pay too much attention that far down the depth chart but pure feeling wise I don't think Davi ever starts a game at VT with Brand in the fold and the transfer portal the way it is today its pretty hard to predict next year let alone 2-3 years out but I think Brand passes Davi just based on HS performance.

(add if applicable) /s

Isn't brand the one who is likely to change positions?

"That's it guys. Let's get out of here. That cold drink's waitin' on us, let's go." - Mike Young after win no. 300.

The deciding factor between us and SCar was that we would look at him at QB. SCar wanted him at DB. He's definitely a project but has some pure arm talent.

(add if applicable) /s

Just my opinion, but Davi had way better HS film. Brand had video game numbers, his film was meh. His highlights were all throws rolling to his right, not in the pocket or rolling left. I think Brand would need to make major strides to have success in the ACC. Maybe he can do it, but I wouldn't assume so based on HS film highlights.

Davi's biggest issue is he is smaller than Pop. Hard to be a pocket passer and visualize the field with 9+ dudes surrounding you and all are 4 to 8 inches taller than you.

I'm not convinced that VT has an elite QB on its roster. Maybe it's Pop, but I haven't really seen anything that says it's definitely him.

πŸ¦ƒ πŸ¦ƒ πŸ¦ƒ

I don't think Davi ever sees the field

Outside it's night time, but inside it's LeDay

Davi is too small. His stature makes him look like Colandrea out there. Love the kid, and I think he has the right attitude and work ethic. He's just small. Just wasn't blessed with size.

From the 2018 VT-uva game-"This is when LEGENDS are made!"

I'm also on the Davi train. No idea if he'll be any good, but I feel like he has the work ethic, the access to great coaching, and athlete genetics. We'll see what happens.

To quote the Brothers Osborne: "I'm Good For Some But I'm Not For Everyone"

Fontel doing work on the recruiting trail again. That man has been incredible the past few years.

Plan for the worst and hope for the best, not the other way around.

If Pry doesn't work out maybe we pull a Clemson and hire the WR coach as our head coach and go on to win a couple nattys.

Great. Now let's keep him in the boat till then.

June 2025 update: welp

21st century QBs Undefeated vs UVA:
MV7, MV5, LT3, Grant Wells, Braxton Burmeister, Ryan Willis, Josh Jackson, Jerod Evans, Michael Brewer, Tyrod Taylor, Sean Glennon, and Grant Noel. That's right, UVA. You couldn't beat Grant Noel.

This used to be a concern sure - flipping recruits is nothing new. Now in 2025 it's a red alarm fire of course as he is going to be recruited harder than ever now and offered tons of cash from someone.

Its like having the first pick in a White Elephant holiday party and choosing the best one.

"When I was growing up, Virginia Tech was a school that was kicking ass and taking names, and it's time we get back to that" - James Franklin

Give us a participation medal because we kept him in the boat for five months. Decommited this morning, leaving us with two recruits in the class of '26. One of those being a kicker. Everything is fine tho.

Fire Whit.

Thanks for wasting money on me Blacksburg so I could raise my profile and leave for more money anyway. Appreciate ya blacksburg

Why am I not surprised?

Recovering scientist working in business consulting

When I saw 25 new comments in this thread, I knew what that meant.

"Yes I am going to have favorites. My favorites are high production and low maintenance players, coaches, and staff." - JMFF

At first I was like "Alright!!" then I looked at the date and was like "Oh...alright..."

If you don't want to recruit clowns, don't run a clown show.

"I want to punch people from UVA right in the neck." - Colin Cowherd

Yup. Same old shit.

At this point recruiting to me is back to the late 90s. you start paying attention to the recruiting class once you see the list of signed players. No point in paying attention until then.

Plan for the worst and hope for the best, not the other way around.

have we even had a "monthly" recruiting thread yet in 2025?

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Been hundreds of offers announced. I retweet them but as most have indicated here, it's just not worth the time to type up, especially with how little momentum this staff seems to have with the next class.

Perfect example here. "Commitment" ceremony this Saturday between us and Georgia Tech

Rob Peterson
VTCC
Charlie/Hotel Company
Class of 1999

We're currently being out recruited by JMU. Pathetic.

You do realize they are going to beat us by 10 points in Lane next year, right? Brace yourself. They won't be the team with false starts, turnovers, penalties. That will be the team in Maroon and Orange. Lock.

It's happened before.

"Yes I am going to have favorites. My favorites are high production and low maintenance players, coaches, and staff." - JMFF

That was painful to watch. The run of redemption wins after this game was an epic stretch of VT football. Unfortunately shitting the bed in the Orange Bowl was the perfect bookend to a season that had much more potential

You're better off just waiting until signing day. In today's landscape, there is literally no reason to get excited when a player commits to your school, especially when it's in January.

Bleeding burnt orange and chicago maroon

At this point why bother recruiting? Just send out offer letters with a salary attached after others have set the market.

"When I was growing up, Virginia Tech was a school that was kicking ass and taking names, and it's time we get back to that" - James Franklin

What a shitshow this whole sport has become.

we are currently dead last in the ACC in recruiting. we have 2 commits. no other ACC school has less than 5. most have 10+. this class could be worse than any of fuente's classes. at this rate, Price is gonna get a chance to be head coach again for a few more games this year.

I think that budget report that had us 13th in the ACC should already tell you we are not getting better any time soon, at least not without a change in leadership.

Just more evidence that our school doesn't care.

"When I was growing up, Virginia Tech was a school that was kicking ass and taking names, and it's time we get back to that" - James Franklin

The fact that we didnt fire Pry after the Miami game showed that we dont care. Just like Fuente should have been gone after ODU and Frank after JMU.

Frank after JMU

A little extreme on that take. We did go undefeated in the ACC that year.

I mean at that point Frank earned retirement at the end of the year, but that was the end for him. Sure he went undefeated in the ACC which had 3 teams with >.500 records and a 4th in FSU in the championship game. We beat obe 10 win teams, one 9 win teams, one 8 win team and one 7 win team. We had 3 of the best backs VT has had with 2 WRs that would end their careers at the top of VTs record book, and the 2nd best QB in the history of VT, and we couldn't get 1 yard against a 1AA team.

In 2011 we weren't much of a team, we had a ton of great players but we came the closest to being shut out since 1995 to a team that gave up 70 to WVU. We beat 5 teams with winning records Ark St which had 10 wins, but you best win was against an 8-5 UVA team. That doesn't sound like a great season. We had insane talent but we weren't as good of a team as the talent we had.

After than we didn't have the talent cause we had a couple of bad classes, it really was a sign that Beamers time was coming to an end.

This is a very interesting take. You have very high standards. I get that it may have been possible to see that we were at the beginning of the downward trend, but many fanbases would kill for back to back 10 win seasons with a conference championship

Virginia Tech School of Architecture Class of 2014
Fan of Hokies, Ravens, NY Giants, Orioles

Oh I enjoyed those seasons other than JMU game. I enjoyed last season too. But if the goal is stated to win championships then you cant lose to 1-AA. And you cant keep a coach that has the clock management skills of James Franklin with out the recruiting skills and expect to win games.

yeah, JMU - at the time a total non factor making mental prep hard- in a driving rain fluke game, you don't fire a hall of fame coach who went on to win an ACC title that year. it's not comparable to Trevon Hill taking swings at coaches and a non D1 QB lighting up bud for 600 yards or Pry being incompetent in every close game. not comparable. How close is Pry to winning the ACC?

I would figure you would want that. You talk about how we dont have the right mentallity in Blacksburg for winning championships. Losing to 1AA should be unacceptable if you want to win at the highest level. They would have had a losing record if we had won.

You said in another thread that we should be prepared to lose to JMU by 10 this year. We'll they are a way better football team now, there should be way less shame in losing now they are atleast in the same subdivision. They now have the same number of scholarships.

National Champion coaches dont have fluke games that late into their time at a school when they are at the top of their game.

Beamer had a bad game- well 2 really. I thought ECU the week before was worse loss with the Tyrod debacle. That said, 2 games into the season after his body of work, you don't fire him.

I did update that in a response that he earned ti retire at the end if the season a la Lloyd carr

Boise was the week before the JMU rain game.

People tend to forget that hat JMU game was the perfect alignment of factors against a VT win.

Most important factor was the Boise St game the week before. It was a physically hard-fought game late on a Monday Night that ended in an emotionally devastating loss. Most people don't understand how long it takes to physically recover from a football game and to prepare for the next one. It's a major reason why Thu Night NFL games tend to be kind of ass. A typical game week is game on Sat, rest Sun (and sometimes Mon), recovery, practice, and game prep Mon-Fri. That week they didn't even get back to Blacksburg until Tuesday morning so that day was a complete wash. That left just Wed-Fri for recovery and game prep for JMU. But the players were answering questions all week from reporters about the devastating Boise St loss. You could sense that they hadn't moved on mentally and the reporters weren't exactly helping by constantly asking about it.

Second factor is that Mikey Matthews (JMU's coach) was a good football coach. He literally said in a radio interview the following Mon was that he knew that VT's players would be beat up and still physically recovering from Boise St. He then said that they kept talking about that game in interviews so he knew that they wouldn't be mentally ready. So he made the smart decision to switch to an option-based offense, that they didn't use the week before, to take advantage of VT's mental and physical fatigue and to try to milk the clock to limit VT's offenses opportunities. VT had no way of expecting that switch so the defense, already slowed down due to fatigue, were completely caught off guard. By the time they could adjust, it was too late.

Then add in the rain. A wet field slows down a defense. So a VT defense already slowed down by fatigue and slowed down even more by trying to think and react to a completely unexpected option-based offense now had to contend with that, too. You could see how the players just looked sluggish, like even when they wanted to move, their bodies were just having a really hard time functioning.

VT's offense wasn't exactly a juggernaut to begin with. The whole game plan was to try to out muscle the opponent at the point of attack and run the ball down their throats, because "it's just JMU", surely we can push them around. It's pretty hard to do that when you're exhausted and the other guy is fresh, even if you're the superior athlete. Add in the limited number of possessions due to JMU milking the clock and its a recipe for disaster. I firmly believe that Darren Evans doesn't fumble the ball on that last drive and VT scores if the Boise St game was on the previous Sat.

It was literally the perfect storm. I have nothing but respect for the leadership on that team that had the closed-door, player's-only meeting that is credited with helping the team move on and to just roll through the rest of the conference.

"Nope, launch him into the sun and fart on him on the way up"
-gobble gobble chumps

"11-0, bro"
-Hunter Carpenter (probably)

You wrote it up perfectly.

I also remember the discussion that started right after the schedule came out naming the JMU game as difficult for the very reason you stated. Would have been better if it was a bye week or Thurs night game after the Monday at Boise.

This is going to be great for the ACC.

Wait, why after Miami? Sure, we lost* the game, but we were competitive against a damn good Miami team. What do you expect?

* by conference orders

"Yes I am going to have favorites. My favorites are high production and low maintenance players, coaches, and staff." - JMFF

it was very clear Pry cant coach, he blew the last drive on shitty clock management. We could have had 2-3 more shots at the endzone if he could coach.

The end of the first half was worse. 1. not knowing that forward progress rolls the clock (coaching 101) and wasting a time out to give miami a free 2 downs.. 2. You make it worse by calling a defense that allows them a wide open WR in FG range. awful.

Two words - lame duck. And I think most everybody knows it by now.

Never got remotely excited about him. Wouldn't have even if he'd signed. Probably wouldn't have seen the field as a true freshman, which means at least two portal opportunities to leave without making any impact at all. The time to care is when fall practice opens, and the people to care about are in the two-deep. Anybody else is just guys who haven't left yet, to my mind.

You do realize that posts like these totally contradict needing to beat UVA to be bowl eligible every year, right? If these kids aren't better than the kids that lose to Vandy and Duke, then our recruiting is worse than you think it is. Think about it. We don't win, yet this kid had no hopes of seeing the field.

Development and game management plays a role too it's not literally all recruiting. Pry lost 4 games due to bad game management, we could technically go 9-3 next year with a less talented team if the coaching improves

Solid premise on paper. We won't win close to 9 games in 25

I just had this conversation with my son last night over a few beers on the front porch. It wouldn't surprise me if we see the same scenarios this season and for whatever miraculous reason Pry wins all the close games via sound game management and checks off 9 in the W column.

Could happen, but where are the 9? Our best teams would lose the type of game South Carolina is- big, neutral site etc. You don't think Shane- who has a top 15 type team- doesn't want to give Whit a big middle finger? you bet your ass he does. They will be prepared, and newsflash- Shane is a good coach anyway. Whit fired him essentially. I fully expect FSU to be a top 15, possibly top 10 team this year- talent wins in the end. Vandy beat us last year when we had Peebles, Delane, Strong, APR etc. our defense is not near that good this year. Their coach is better than Pry too. So we winning all of the others? Miami? Louisville? at GT? respectfully, nah

All of that is understood. My comment was purely figurative as in, last season should have been the 9 win season and wasn't due to a far greater level of buffoonery to overcome.

This season, from a literal perspective I don't see 9 wins. I think 99% of us don't see 9 wins.

If for some "miraculous" reason we win 9 it will be as big a head scratcher as last season's results. Won't make sense. No logic just a "WTF season that was, but I'll take it".

13-0

This is going to be great for the ACC.

Newsflash tech fans- hey we suck at football