
Brace yourself, it's time for meta.
At the beginning of the year I posted The Key Play's 2014 Metrics, 2015 State of TKP and TELL-a-thon 2.0. It included a summary of website statistics, demographics, a survey, my rationale for keeping TKP free, its need for money and plans in 2015. I sincerely appreciate the wonderful feedback in the survey. Any good business is going to solicit and listen to advice from its customers, and over the course of the last 2.5 months I've tried to improve upon the most common suggestions from the 645 of you that responded.
robobuilder nudged me a few weeks ago and asked for an update. My original plan was to publish what you're reading now on March, 14, TKP's 5th birthday (only 13 more years until I can boot this thing out the door), but it was a Saturday and I just started writing this at 11:19 PM, March, 17. I've been entrenched coding updates for TKP, many of which are already in production, and haven't had time to focus on anything else. I'll discuss more about what's new in a minute, but first some pretty charts from the survey.
The TKP'er who identified their gender with "sexual tyrannosaurus" was a lurker, which is disappointing because I was hoping for an explanation.
Age skews as I expected, 18-34 is the overwhelming majority of users. 1995 Sugar Bowl highlights, since that game was probably before most of our times (mine included).
That's pretty a pretty powerful message. If you've ever thought of advertising with TKP...
There's not enough data to draw any conclusion from this. It's a question I'll ask in subsequent years.
If you wondered why so much coverage was devoted to Buzzketball, that's your answer. And kudos to Brian and Pierson for delivering fresh insights throughout the season.
Substantial updates have been made to TKP's technology stack to address specific problems.
1. Search has been overhauled. The previous version was butts, and the new search is fast and is indexed directly from TKP's database to provide the best results. I also added a title filter to the tracker as another means to find threads.
2. I added a toggle switch to comments. If you click the switch it will dim all the other comments except for the current comment and all of its ancestors. Another way to think about it is the switch highlights the current family of comments by dimming all other comments.
You can flick any switch in that comment's "family" to turn all the comments back on, or click a dimmed switch to highlight a new family. Folks asked for a better way to visualize / find parent comments, and this is what I came up with. I didn't want lines all over the page, and I think it works well. If you're in a long thread with a lot of branching comments, you can flick a switch, then scroll up and easily see all the relevant replies.
3. Collapsable comments are also a thing. Click the ∨ in the comment header to collapse a thread, then > to expand it.
Collapsed threads are remembered on a per device basis. I used cookies to store the data, and more often than not those won't sync between devices. So in most circumstances if you collapse a thread on your laptop, and view it on your iPhone, it won't be collapsed. If you collapse a comment, all the comments threaded underneath will be collapsed too, the same thing happens when you expand. This should be a quick and easy way to ignore a section of a comment thread, or make a longer thread more manageable to navigate.
Expect more updates to be rolled out throughout spring and summer. TKP is an agile technology company as much it is a media business.
I wrote the following before I hit you all up for cash in January.
My plan for The Key Play in 2015 is to: 1) grow non-revenue sports coverage; 2) expand existing football, basketball and high school recruiting coverage; 3) find a couple of new voices to add to TKP's already diverse offering (if you're interested); 4) update TKP's technology stack (beginning with an improved search experience); and 5) be TKP's best year yet.
Point Five is still a work in progress, as it's only March, but otherwise things are going as I planned. Alex did an excellent job shining the light on Tech's wrestling program as well as cranking out recruiting features. Joey Coogan's baseball coverage has been fantastic. French, Mason, Alex and Will, will all cover spring football—we'll try not to overwhelm you.
According to the survey, 553 of you indicated The Key Play was worth something to you when asked "Hypothetical: If The Key Play became a subscription website, how much would you pay for a subscription per month?".
Thus far in 2015, 152 of your have supported TKP. As of March 17, readers have generously given The Key Play $4,012.42 in one-time payments in 2015, and 32 people are on a recurring plan to give a total of $172.50 a month.
Those of you who think TKP's worth a subscription fee, or those that have been on the fence about making a financial contribution, I need your help to keep The Key Play growing. Any contribution, whatever you're generous enough to give, will help make TKP a community that can better serve you.
The major vision of Orange and Maroon Media, LLC, the business that owns The Key Play, is to hire its first full-time employee, a beat writer that answers to, and works for you, the diehard Hokie fan. In order to even consider that a possibility, financial support from the readership needs to hit $40,000 a year.
1. Click the PayPal button below to financially support TKP. And if you really want to be an All-American, make it a recurring payment. If you're a registered user, you'll get a gold star next to your user name. If you're a lurker, you'll get a sincere thank you email.
1a. Because this question has been asked more than once... If you don't have a PayPal account and want to mail a check:
Orange and Maroon Media, LLC
3057 Nutley Street, Suite 633
Fairfax, Virginia 22031
2. Buy The Key Play merchandise in our online store: shop.thekeyplay.com.
3. Shop at Amazon with this link
4. If you own or represent a business consider purchasing a sponsorship \ advertisement on The Key Play.
5. Share the stories and articles we publish via Email, Facebook and Twitter.
6. Organic growth has been a key to TKP's success. A good deal of Hokie Nation knows about the website, but many folks do not. I need your help to reach those people who don't have Twitter or Facebook, who have never seen one of French's film reviews, or who are stepping foot on campus for the first time. Would you tell a friend or friends about the website the next time you're discussing the Hokies?
Thank you for your continued patience, patronage and support.
Comments
1.1 per cent over 65? Way to make me me feel damn old. Get off my damn lawn!
Sweet, 1/32! My recurring payment is tiny, but I figure a small predictable payment is better than a random chunk of money whenever I remember.
What about a Reddit Gold style system for comments? Make it cost a few bucks and let people gild awesome comments. Might be a nice way to incentivize donations and also reward good/funny commenters.
Every little bit adds up and the recurring feature on PayPal seems like a great option.
This is the holy grail and it's something I've considered. However, it's well beyond the scope of the PayPal system I use now and would take quite a bit of engineering to do right. I won't have time for it this offseason, but building TKP's own gild system might be a thing next year.
So there is this awesome movie from the 80's which taught us that if you chew tobacco you become a sexual tyrannosaurs just like Jessie "The Body" Ventura (this was his pre douchebag days when he was just a wrastler). Always glad to help you youngins out ;)
http://www.bing.com/images/search?q=sexual+tyrannosaurus+predator&qpvt=s...
Did you just use bing to search? Nothing shows your age more than that...unless you went to yahoo.com and searched for bing first.
Edit: I just checked your profile and you are only 3 months older than me (DAMMIT!), but we were both in the Endzone for the 99 Miami game. Do you remember the bleachers swaying because it was over capacity?
I think not knowing how to embed gif's, pictures, meme's, etc shows my age pretty well... ;)
I'll admit to using Bing for searches because if you search enough you get free gift cards. If I need to use Google for a search I still have that option, but I've gotten about $25 in Amazon gift cards over the last 1-2 years from making Bing my default.
I use it exclusively at work and I've been saving up the points for whenever I need to buy a month of Hulu Plus or something like that. I've got enough for nearly 10 months of it at this point which will be nice if I ever commit to going the "cable cutting" route.
cough * projectfreetv * cough * videobull * cough
Posting to be able to find this later regarding alleged TV alternatives
Hypothetically if you have trouble with these hypothetical alternatives you can hypothetically ask me more and I could hypothetically tell you how one might hypothetically do that
If you were to hypothetically offer future hypothetical assistance regarding hypothetical alternatives to TV, then I'd be hypothetically grateful.
If such a thing existed, hypothetically you would want to follow these rules:
Wait HTF does that work?
I also use Bing as my search default at work. But over the past 2+ years, I've earned enough credit for $40 worth of Amazon monies. Basically, you earn credit simply by searching on your phone and/or browser, which can be redeemed for various things. These things vary from sweepstakes entries to gift cards to subscription credit for Hulu and the like. The amount of credits you can earn is capped per day.
You can learn more about it by "binging"(is that a word now?) their rewards program. Now I must go google everything as I now feel like a Microsoft rep.
I'm a gold level Bing member. It takes me 2-3 weeks to earn a $5 Amazon gift card maxing out the searches every day. Sorry, Google.
So if I use Bing to search for Google, and then go to google.com to carry out what I actually want to do, do I still get paid?
Oh my god Bing is killed so thoroughly by Google that Microsoft is now essentially paying customers to user it.
This doesn't sound like a profitable business model to me.
MS will be able to say they still have X amount of people searching, and charging businesses to bid on ad placement for PPC/search/remarketing. So they get $X amount from business for ad placement and MS pays the searcher a few cents per session. 1 + ? = profit.
I was on a call yesterday and saw a hotel I work with was making really good ROI on digital campaigns with Bing. My only question on the call was "who the hell uses Bing?"
Hi
I am the lurker who identified as the Sexual T-rex. I had been watching Predator clips to pass time at work and was annoying my girlfriend with the quotes. I was on a roll and it kind of rolled into this poll.
As a side note, I love First Down and hope you get them as a sponsor again for the next football season. When I heard that Ramesh was going to sponsor last year, I lost my shit and almost registered an account. I decided not to because I couldn't think of a good username.
As it was (almost) said in a Key and Peele sketch: You always had your user name
About your signature...
Are we talking about Dork Magic?
Beat Writer? Who need's a beat writer when we have an entire communications program on campus!?
If we take an comm intern, we can not pay them, as standard with comm majors who are extended internship offers. They need the experience, VT gets their cut by charging them a few G's to accept the credits towards graduation. Heck maybe we can get them to pay us for the internship too!
Seriously though, pay your interns folks, aint nothin' free in this world, especially labor.
As a graduated Comm major, this is a pretty solid idea. Plenty of students in Electronic/Print Journalism (or whatever it's called now) would work for a few months in the fall and/or spring to gain solid undergrad work experience and also cash in enough for beer money on top of that.
This was my thoughts, I just had a meeting to run to before I could post. A lot of communications kids need material to build a resume and would love to work for a place that has media credentials. Plus they are pretty close to the source. Minimum wage is about what everything else around campus pays...
Wait, I thought the comm majors are too busy playing football to write about it **DUCKS**
Here's the basic model already laid out for you.
I appreciate your thought. TKP's given many students, comm or otherwise, an opportunity to write. Brian, Will, Joey, Kevin Burke (from back in the day) and it's worked out well. However, it's a serious time investment on my part to onboard, manage and educate them throughout their tenure. Time is a limited resource I'm out of. Not only that, but they have school and a social life to manage.
A full-time employee would be able to focus exclusively on TKP and own the Virginia Tech beat. And anyone I would hire would have the prior experience necessary to work independently with little micromanagement.
I come here for the specific purpose of being overwhelmed with coverage.
Please please please overwhelm me. My body is ready
Have you thought about starting a Patreon account? That could help bring in a reliable stream of donations.
I've never been so happy to give away my money.
I've said it before, but I can't say it enough, Joe and Co., you guys run the best VT website there is. The amount of consideration you put towards the readers is almost unheard of.
I don't know how I never noticed the Amazon-TKP link at the top-right of the page. Considering I shop all the time on Amazon, that's a great way to continuously contribute something which is always better than nothing. Pretty neat-o!
THIS! I'm trying to find a way to work recurring donations into my budget, but until then, I make all my amazon purchases through this link.
The great thing about this site is the community and that it's free to the public.
If my new monthly payments helps keep this site as great as it is and free for most, then I have no problem paying a monthly 'subscription' to keep it that way.
Thanks for all your hard work Joe and the rest of your staff!
Well if TKP switches to subscription only or splits its content between subscription only and free sides, then "it won't be free the public anymore" which will kill the great thing about this site as you point out. If it splits content, TKP staff will be forced to put most of their content or at least the best part of its content on the subscription only side, then the free side would deteriorate into nothing and then TKP would lose the great thing it has right now. I for one would vote for TKP to just stay exactly as it is now. Why does it have to grow if it already is right at the sweet spot in terms of "just the right amount of coverage"? What's wrong with just maintaining a kick-ass Free Hokie site that all Hokies can enjoy? The problems with other Hokie subscription sites is that, well...they are not free and you have to have a subscription to view their good content - and I'll add that the interaction and posts between fans is separated by the subscription split.
The plan is for it to remain free. The separation of content and community arguments you made are valid and something I immediately realized when I first publicly said I was going to make it a pay website. Folks contribute what they can, when they can.
If you're not getting better, you're getting worse. I don't do things halfassed. The goal of TKP will always be to provide the best coverage. It's just how I tick.
I never said to move to subscriptions or split the content. I hope the site stays free, all of the content is free, and that I'm now willing to pay a reoccurring fee, which I consider to myself as a personal 'subscription', to keep it that way.
Apologies for being ambiguous.
I know my tell-a-thon efforts have picked up at least two daily readers, I also see people I know posting TKP links in their Facebook. hopefully this lets Joe charge more for ad space. I spread the word when other Hokies if I have heard anything lately
I made y contribution. Love the site. Hope it stays free. At this point I'd pay for the content
Joe, going to be in the States later this Spring/Summer. Will get something set up with my parents or brother. Still having issues with paypall, it just doesn't work well with my China bank account and I have no US account. Not surprising though. Anyway, sorry for delay but will get it to you one way or the other.
Yo, if you're in the DC area - I owe you a beer or two.
Nice. Definitely trying to make it back East as well. I'll have my wife and 3 year old daughter with me, so you bring us to some killer crab cakes and we're square. I'll let you know when we finally work things out. This year has been crazy busy and it just keeps getting more crazy, so gotta find the time to leave. Will be great catching up again.
Keep us posted. I'm just outside of DC and I work in Baltimore. Beers and local fare would be fun.
THE Guitarman?!
Just going to warn you, if we meet and I don't see your pockets overflowing with turkey legs I am going to be severely disappointed.
Seriously though that would be awesome. Will definitely let you guys know. Would be really cool to catch up with everyone. And if I don't make it back East this trip I was thinking about doing a return in the Fall for a game.
I don't know about pockets, but the contents of my smoker when fall rolls around are usually...
you had me at "smoker"
also, Jerry Maguire's Renee Zellweger what happened to you?
No apology is necessary!
Request for the almighty Joe:
Would it be difficult to add an 'm' hotkey that would let a user jump to his/her comments ('m' for me) within a thread? Right now I just go to 'my comments', click on the desired thread, and ctrl+F my username.
That's a very good idea, and yes it's something I can do and will do.
BEST
brilliant idea, by the way
What I've been trying to figure out is how to scroll to the next new comment on a mobile device. I can't bring up the keyboard unless I am actually typing something on my phone.
Edit: I don't think this is something Joe can solve.
It's something I've been thinking about. I don't think hitting a key on a mobile device is a feasible solution. However...
What I'm planning on doing is adding a bar with buttons [N][T][M][^] overlayed on the bottom of the page whenever the user is browsing the comments. It would scroll with the page like the menubar at the top of TKP does on a desktop. Then the user would just have to tap an [N] to go to the previous new comment. [^] would switch [N][T][M] to [n][t][m] and the direction of the jump.
Since we're talking narcissistic self stalking, could you add up vote/turkey leg count to the comments you see on the comments page? It's nice to know that someone has replied but sometimes you just want to know if people thought you were funny.
I'm sooooo guilty of this...
Neat. I'd like to have the hashtag on the comments page so I can link direct to a comment. The only option from that page currently is to click the thread title and search for the comment on the page. Control F is a functional alternative when you get to the thread.
So for a given thread, you want to see the total number of turkey legs for all the comments in that thread?
I think he's talking about the "comments" tab: right now it doesn't show the leg score. So if you wanted to say, see how your comments were doing, you have to click on each one to see its score.
Couldn't have said it better myself. No, I literally couldn't. I just re-read my comment and I'm not entirely sure it says what I meant to say.
When it comes to raising money, I've always thought having a visible goal helps to make people contribute. Keep it somewhere on the front page with " we have xxx dollars to go!"
Also, have you though about just having a week/ other period of time to have a big push for a fundraiser? Just a thought.
Thanks for all you guys do
A lot of sites do those fundraisers to cover hosting costs. It would be an interesting case study to see if that would work here.
Bitcoin?
I'm probably the only one wishing to do this so I'll def understand if this doesn't get a reply, but is there any way there could be a feature to change your username on here similar to Twitter? This is just due to the fact I was an idiot and chose my real name when I made my account on here, and besides the people who write for TKP, I know no one else who does this. Thanks for all your hard work Joe, I know it's not as easy as you make it all look
honestly, I thought your user name was an inside joke. But now that I know it is in fact your real name....
Thanks for laughing at both my name and stupidity. That gif is also horrifying haha
my pleasure. Also don't be surprised when you start getting emails from JDate and people you swiped right to on tinder & Grindr. plus those 50 pizzas will be totally worth the money, I remembered to order extra anchovy & Canadian bacon only. just how you like it.
Of course, you can just petition joe to change your username. He is the great and powerful admin, you know. Of course, your success is completely dependent on his mood. We serve at the mercy of a capricious editor...
I'm getting my money's worth
Random FYI knowledge... I played in the halftime show at that '95 sugar bowl. That game started me on my journey to Hokie fandom! Good times seeing that posted up there!