Recent Comments

Shai is clearly our most talented natural running back.

starts off alright...

Marshawn isn't explosive/fast enough to be a star but is still a solid college RB and situational runner.

this is what everyone said about Darren Evans and then Maryland game happened.

MacMillan is a total unknown at this point but has athletic upside.

He's a redhsirt freshman who excelled on scout team and has been acclaimed spring, summer and now fall. Not really an unknown.

JC is being overhyped to an uncomfortable level as the #1 back – he can be a good role player but he has only ever produced in spurts – I hope I'm wrong.

the last 4 games of last season proves this wrong.

Long story short – no real horse in this mix.

Bruce and Stew did an episode of the Audible (podcast) where they discussed the ACC. Bruce basically said that he can't predict the Hokies winning the ACC until we show a sign of life on offense. Which we didn't do in consecutive games all year last season.

There's a growing sentiment that any member of the media who doesn't pick us to win the ACC is either a moron or is lazy and hasn't put in his due diligence. If any other team that scored 0 points in 4 quarters against one of the 20 worst P5 teams said that their offense would be suitable based on a spring game performance, I would laugh at them. Let's have some perspective.

There is a reason we are considering five guys, they all have their positives and negatives:
JCC -- Pro - Finished the season strong when he got enough carries, notably against UVA (a top 25 defense against the run) when he was beat up and frigid....he's also the 2nd best breakaway speed guy we have and should be good catching the ball in open space (although we are so bad running traditional screen plays you question how important that is) Con - Has never been strong in the redzone, concerns with pass protection, has had some big fumbles

Edmunds -- Pros - Good pass catcher (TD against UVA in '13), versatile between tackles/outside, good redzone back (Miami '13), good pass protection, beefed up to 225 lbs this year Cons -- May not be a natural RB (seems to almost gallup at times, not quick and needs space to gain top speed), injuries

McKenzie -- Pros - Heavy shoulder, good redzone back, Lee Suggs forward lean Cons -- Inexperience, bad knees, has not demonstrated pass catching/pass protection abilities but may possess them

Marshawn -- Pros - A horse, tough to bring down, good in the redzone, tenacious Cons -- Fumble risk (OSU non-fumble is tough to get out of your mind)...may be a fumble risk because he fights for every last inch, injury history, needs to keep weight in check

MacMillian -- Pros - Outside speed, playmaker that the rest of the group lacks... Cons -- Inexperienced, not expected to be as good between tackles as others.

I mean he went to 'school' at UNC and is now at UVa.

The guy has already suffered enough. This is just cruel

You should have. I lost mine a little bit while in Florida for 4 years but now that I'm back in NC, the accent is no longer a negative tell on my intelligence, but an indicator of trustworthiness for my coworkers and the public that I deal with.

True. I think last year we were going to see less of the insane rotation. Shane's comments quoted here indicate a significant departure in intent from years past, so it definitely sounds like he has changed his opinion and understands that unless your guy is an absolute superstar, most backs need sustained action to get into the rhythm of each game. It just doesn't carry over week to week, opponent to opponent.

I can't help but look at the injuries last year being a blessing in disguise in the regard that it opened his eyes to this after our 5th string guy had such success at the end of the year. JCC is one of my favorite hokies, but he doesn't have the upside of the other backs. He had the success he did in no small part because he had the contiguous snaps, & didn't have the nagging fear that he was going to get pulled for no apparent reason and could just focus on the field.

It always catches me by surprise. I hear Go Hokies while out somewhere and I stagger for a second or two, then look around to find the person and answer them back. My default setting in public is that I'm no one anyone wants to talk to so no one is going to talk to me, unless to say excuse me if I'm in their way.

By the way, congrats on 7k legs.

Did he transfer or did he move under the grad rules with a year of eligibility left?

Yeah, this is great and all, but we still need to remember that this happened just around nine months ago...

8-4 and a decent bowl game is probably more on tap if the Hokies can't stop the blitz and keep Brewer upright.

It's so weird that UNC let him transfer to UVA. They could have blocked that.

Pages