OT: "The Mandalorian" S3 discussion thread (feat. Spoilers)

🎢🎡 doo-dooooo 🎡🎢

It's finally back!! A detour in Book of Boba Fett reunited us viewers with Din and Grogu. Where do they go from here?

Forums: 
DISCLAIMER: Forum topics may not have been written or edited by The Key Play staff.

Comments

This is the way.

2023 Season Challenge: TBD
Previous Challenges: Star Wars (2019), Marvel (2020), Batman (2021), Wrasslin' (2022)

This is the way.

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Just finished andor last week. This is perfect timing!

Twitter me

Season premiere scratches even the itches i didnt know i had lol

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

The Mandalorian and Andor...are better than any of the actual SW 9 main movies. ESB is right there, but other than that...

2023 Season Challenge: TBD
Previous Challenges: Star Wars (2019), Marvel (2020), Batman (2021), Wrasslin' (2022)

If by a hot take you mean absurd. Star Wars is one of the most important and groundbreaking movies in history, and Empire Strikes Back is widely regarded as somehow actually improving on in. They both hold up amazingly well even 40+ years later.

The Mandalorian is a well-done and fun TV show. But better than the movies that set the standard for science fiction for decades? Please pass me the bottle of whatever you all are drinking.

The doll's trying to kill me and the toaster's been laughing at me.

That's because Andor isn't a Star Wars series.

It is a series that just happens to be set in the Star Wars Universe.

Never Forget #1 Overall Seed UVA 54, #64 UMBC 74

It's Blade Runner in the Star Wars universe.

I would argue it's still a Star Wars series, not simply "set in".

It's an amazing depiction of what's going on in that massive universe that doesn't involve laser swords and a few heroes.

When a story can make the Empire look more compelling, competent, menacing, and straight up evil then when they were straight up blowing up planets...it's a Star Wars series.

This is how I see Mandalorian and Andor:

Mandalorian = Saturday morning cartoon
Andor = HBO Sunday night drama

Two entirely different shows, but I strongly prefer Andor

The Mandalorian and Andor...are better than any of the actual SW 9 main movies.

AGREED

ESB is right there

Maybe it's because I was born years after RotJ, and knew that Vader was Luke's father before ever seeing the movies, but I never thought ESB was that great. It felt incomplete and that always irritated me. Probably why RotJ is my favorite of the movies.

Twitter me

I know my fellow Rebels fans got REAL excited when they were in hyperspace

Darn tooting i did. Filoni/Favreau doing some heavy lifting to contextualize for casual fans what we assume will be the major plot of Ahsoka later on this year

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Are you guys referring to those giant hyperspace creatures that were moving alongside them?

Yes, the purrgil. They are basically hyperspace-enabled space whales and they play a key role in rebels -- and to this point, have only appeared in rebels

edit: rebels is absolutely worth watching. art style is different and the story takes a little bit to get into, but boy are the highs of that show VERY high and it does help build lore of mandalorian culture

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

There was a moment when the wife and I were watching this and we saw the outlines to the Space Whales in hyperspace and it took a bit for us to connect them. Not gonna lie at first we thought it was a reference to the space whales in Doctor Who and I was confused, yet excited, at the cross-over. Then I remember the purrgil from Rebels.

I found TKP after two rails from TOTS then walking back to my apartment and re-watching the 2012 Sugar Bowl. I woke up the next day with this username.

Can you explain this to a fairweather starwars fan?

Twitter me

I'll take a stab.

They are whale creatures that travel through Hyperspace and I think are force sensitive (somebody double check me on that), so they're rarely seen. In Star Wars Rebels: the main character (Ezra) summons them in the finale and he and the main villain get sucked away by them somewhere into hyperspace.

Rumors are that the plot of the Ahsoka show will be Ahsoka and some other characters from Rebels trying to find Ezra

Dont think they're inherently force sensitive but ezra did form some sort of connection to them. Don't remember if it was force-y or not

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Ezra was force connected with them and used that connection to remove Thrawn.

I think it's more that any living thing that can navigate hyperspace is force-connected to a degree. Canon thrawn trilogies seem to confirm that, so i was wrong. Initially i was thinking Ezra bonded with them the way he bonded with the Loth Wolves (and like how weve seen grogu "tame" animals like the mudhorn, rancor, etc)

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

I'm pretty sure he's force connected. there would be no reason for the purrgil to do what they did when the took Thrawn unless Ezra was connected and made it happen.

https://starwars.fandom.com/wiki/Purrgil if you want the deep dive on where they show up in the canon storyline

2023 Season Challenge: TBD
Previous Challenges: Star Wars (2019), Marvel (2020), Batman (2021), Wrasslin' (2022)

If we're gonna have giant alien alligators, I'm gonna need an alien Troy Landry yelling "Choot em!"

My biggest complaint about this show is that every episode feels like it ends about 5-10 mins too early.

That's not necessarily a bad thing, the show is excellent, it just always has a bit of a frustration when the end credits come up

This is my school
This is home

This couldn't have been expressed any better. Watching that episode yesterday, I just wanted...more.

Every episode feels like it takes a few mins to really hit its stride, and once you're settled in, its just.... over

This is my school
This is home

A lot of the more recent SW shows they've been debuting with double episodes, so it was especially jarring when this new season just had a standard 1 episode (30 min) debut.

I also would have loved for it to be twice as long, yet it does some really good contextualizing after such a long time since S2 ended

reinforces Din's drive to atone for removing his helmet (or establishes it for those who skipped BOBF), reinforces the Darksaber's importance to Mandalore and specifically what it meant to Bo-Katan, illustrates the Nevarro revival and sets the stage for conflict there. From what we've seen in the trailer, could the Mandalorian covert find a home in Nevarro to protect them from the pirates? perhaps most importantly, it retcons the existence of Babu Frik

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Good episode. While not groundbreaking it does effectively set the course for S3 and I feel like we as the audience have direction on where this is headed. Also I continue to love the Wild West influences (shootout at the Greef Karga Saloon).

I found TKP after two rails from TOTS then walking back to my apartment and re-watching the 2012 Sugar Bowl. I woke up the next day with this username.

(shootout at the Greef Karga Saloon school)

FTFY

Ok, IG crawling around with 1 arm was a total homage to the end of the original terminator. It even looked like stop motion.

Undo the calamity that is your mammaries

I enjoyed the episode, especially the hyperspace critters bit.

I also really enjoyed that they showed hyperspace taking time. The last three movies really implied this idea of instant hyperspace travel which causes all sort of story problems if distance is meaningless and didn't align really well with how it was portrayed elsewhere in Star Wars.

My only real gripe is that the pirates felt bolted on. Kind of wish there had been a little more setup to that (both school and space). I get the feeling it will pay off later though.

I'm with GGC on this one about the pirates. I don't think we've seen the last of Gorian "Mossface" Shard and his merry band of miscreants, but I will admit they felt "old school stormtrooper inept" both on Nevarro and in space.

Inept definitely. But worse, just corny. Like Sleestak levels of corny.

Ya know, I can almost see it...

It's hard to be effective when you're bound by The Pirate's Code!

2023 Season Challenge: TBD
Previous Challenges: Star Wars (2019), Marvel (2020), Batman (2021), Wrasslin' (2022)

More Bo Katan and the mythosaur alive? Yes please, me likey!

VTCC '86 Delta Company, Hokie in Peru, Former Naval Aviator, Former FBISA, Forever married to my VT87 girl. Go VT!

Excellent episode, so many developments. Grogu defeating an enemy, showing responsibility in a task to get help, overcoming fears and working with BK. Mythosaur. Mandalore is breathable. Peli Motto speaking Jawaese!!!!!

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

After a fairly slow, table setting start in episode 1, they really kicked things off this week. That was great.

This episode felt less rushed than the first, and by that I mean it didn't feel like it ended 10 mins too early like so many before it.

That said, gotta love a good cliffhanger. Sets up for a great opening act next week.

This is my school
This is home

Can someone give a background on why Mandalor is destroyed and why there's lots of fake news around it?

Twitter me

The context: Mandalore in the Clone Wars Era was ruled by Dutchess Satine Kryze (Bo Katan's older sister, and Obi-Wan's love interest) who had a pacifist, nonviolent, nonpartisan stance on The Clone Wars -- neutrality to a fault. The pacifist ways were an overcorrection to previous inter-clan violence that was laced into Mandalorian history.

Some radicals, The Death Watch (later becoming known as Children Of The Watch), effectively became terrorists in trying to push Mandalore back into warrior ways from its nonviolent, neutral-to-a-fault stance. Bo-Katan was one of them, once upon a time

Darth Maul recognized the power of Mandalorian warriors, and Death Watch aligned themselves with Maul's Shadow Collective during the tail end of the Clone Wars era in an attempt to fully overthrow Mandalore. These events are shown in S7 of The Clone Wars animated series.

The answer to the your question: After the Clone Wars ended, Mandalore did not agree to fall in line under Palpatine. He decided that total destruction was necessary. So far, that has not really been explicitly shown in tv/movie canon (i am unsure of any books or graphic novels), aside from flashbacks and references and explicitly shown aftermath (as in this episode).

Why is there fake news? Probably to keep the mandalorians scattered and fighting with each other rather than forming into a unified fighting force to be reckoned with. Keeps them "the example" of the empire's might and retribution.

Fully recommend The Clone Wars and Rebels animated series to get into the details of the Manda-lore.

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Okay, what's the timeline (relative to the movies) for all this? I thought Darth Maul dies at the end of Phantom Menace and the Clone wars are between Episode 2 and 3?

Also, presumably (based on Boba Fett's aging throughout all the episodes) there's about 50ish years between Episode 1 and the start of the Mandalorian? Bo Katan looks like she's at most 40, how old was she when she ruled?

Finally - how did Palpatine destroy Mandalor? If the planet is still there, he clearly didn't use the death star.

Fully recommend The Clone Wars and Rebels animated series to get into the details of the Manda-lore.

Sigh... I just can't get into the animated TV series. They just feel like I'm watching children's cartoons. I've tried and just shut them off after 5 minutes. Have a 2nd kiddo joining the fam in July, maybe this will be my boredom TV until CFB season starts...

Twitter me

I thought Darth Maul dies at the end of Phantom Menace

oh my sweet summer child

I just can't get into the animated TV series.

all im going to say is that the style of the animated shows may be childish, but man some of the themes and episodes are HEAVY. Even The Bad Batch (also recommend, S2 airing now) has a lot of grappling with what it means to be human etc.

Between The Clone Wars and Rebels, the characters are compelling. Ahsoka's introduction and coming of age to become imo the most compelling character in-universe, seeing Anakin's heartbreaking and slow descent as the second most-compelling character in-universe, and the entire story arc of Maul as the next-most compelling character

[Edit: imo, the final arc of S7 of The Clone Wars is the perfect interplay of the stories of these three characters, and until Andor came out, S7 of The Clone Wars was my pick for "best Star Wars content". It's THAT good imo]

Bo Katan looks like she's at most 40, how old was she when she ruled?

BK late 40s now, i'd have to check on her actual timeline

Finally - how did Palpatine destroy Mandalor? If the planet is still there, he clearly didn't use the death star.

Rebels explores an imperial weapon that is effective even against Beskar, but that was prior to the destruction of Mandalore. Newest ep of Mando says "fusion bombs". The destruction of mandalore hasn't been explicitly shown or exposited, just alluded to and the aftereffects shown.

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Andor is the best SW content in ages but to me S7 of clone wars is the best since the original trilogies. The story alone is brutal but told so well it's perfection. But in order to fully appreciate season 7 you need to watch the whole series to emotionally invest in the characters before season 7. Pretty sure the weapons hinted in rebels is probably how the empire did it but I'm not sure on the timeline there is all.

Directions from Blacksburg to whoville, go north till you smell it then go east until you step in it

I thought Darth Maul dies at the end of Phantom Menace and the Clone wars are between Episode 2 and 3?

[Narrator]
Welcome to Star Wars, where getting cut in half and falling down an incredibly deep hole is just the beginning of a new chapter in your life! Cast off those silly lower extremities and replace them with cybernetics - hey that stuff worked for Vadar, right? Armed (or legged) with your new limbs and bucketful of hatred, you can venture forth to take over crime syndicates and even entire planets! And after all your galactic shenanigans are done, you can always return to the desert where apparently everything in the Star Wars universe begins and ends.

Hurry and sign up today! If you order now, we'll include another bonus life*, you just pay for shipping and handling.

* - or a spurtle, depends on inventory.

Somehow, Darth Maul has returned

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

I suppose technically getting cut in half, but the wound being cauterized immediately, your main functions of life (heart, brain, lungs, central nervous system in general) would still continue to function for a time.

The shock would kill you of course, but if you were an extremely powerful space wizard...I can buy it.

Do yourself a favor and watch clone wars and rebels and you will learn Maul was a bad bad man who played a big role in the clone wars and beyond. Even makes a cameo in solos movie as well.

He might be my true favorite villain in SW after all the clone wars arcs. He figured out so much as was devastatingly powerful.

Directions from Blacksburg to whoville, go north till you smell it then go east until you step in it

57 min total run time this week should squash some of those complaints. Verrrrry interesting developments!

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Holy crap, that opening sequence. All I've had a chance to see so far

in terms of "omg the implications here", that opening scene is UP THERE in this series

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

I would assume putting the two (three) of them together for the season will have big effects on what happens with Bo-Katan and the hardline Mandolorian faction, and what she does with the mythosaur information.

Also, I don't think it was a throwaway line when she said that was "way too many for an Imperial warlord". A certain blue alien perhaps

Also, I don't think it was a throwaway line when she said that was "way too many for an Imperial warlord". A certain blue alien perhaps

with a plan to use TIE Interceptors (!) to chase Bo Katan away from the bombers carrying out their mission to hit the (current) place of most importance to her (!) and then draw her into an expertly devised trap (!)

that's high key of way more galactic importance (aka Star Wars Cinematic Universe) than BK-Din-Grogu becoming a de facto family. Even any news on Moff Gideon is very small potatoes comparatively

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

That was good stuff. It started strong and ended strong. Admittedly the plot with the doc wasn't entirely captivating until the end, but I'm now very curious where that's going to lead.

And it's always great to see Coruscant.

I found TKP after two rails from TOTS then walking back to my apartment and re-watching the 2012 Sugar Bowl. I woke up the next day with this username.

Yeah the comms officer had me sketched out af really quickly and at no point did i buy the friendliness... but why exactly is she up to what she's up to? Apparently we are watching the beginnings of the shift from New Republic to First Order

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

I'll be honest the whole story with the doc and the comms officer might be one of the weaker bits of storytelling this show has had.

It was obvious immediately that she was up to something, and helping the New Republic was not it. But there were also no hints or clues as to what it actually was. I'm assuming she resisted whatever they did at the reintegration camps, and she's still making moves for Moff Gideon, and is just really good at pretending. Wiping the doc's brain completely would certainly be a good start to hiding what else the remnants of the Empire are up to.

I dug this week's episode. I really like seeing glimpses of the "everyday" life in SW universe so those scenes just walking around Coruscant were awesome. Also getting some perspective on what people and the New Republic were up to post Empire cool too

I'm of two minds on this week's episode (which I enjoyed quite a bit).

1. The story with the remnants of the Empire acquiring cloning technology was interesting as a Star Wars fan.

2. Much like Book of Boba Fett spent an entire episode on Mando side stories, this episode really felt like it didn't belong in the current (very exciting) storyline and pulled me out of it. Hopefully it will still connect like BoBF did.

2023 Season Challenge: TBD
Previous Challenges: Star Wars (2019), Marvel (2020), Batman (2021), Wrasslin' (2022)

i think the connective tissue with both of your points is just how much the show runners in this series are using it as a vehicle to try and contextualize the (awful) sequel trilogy. There needs to be some sort of stage set for how the New Republic turns into the First Order, there needs to be some sort of explanation for whatever tf Snoke was (clone experiment?), there needs to be some sort of explanation for the "somehow" that caused palpatine's return etc etc etc

"Why gobble gobble chumps asks such good questions, I will never know." - TheFifthFuller

Filoni and Favreau Manure Services: Cleaning Up Other People's Dumb Shit

I found TKP after two rails from TOTS then walking back to my apartment and re-watching the 2012 Sugar Bowl. I woke up the next day with this username.

To clarify, the New Republic doesn't "turn into" the First Order. The context of the The Force Awakens is that the New Republic doesn't take the First Order seriously, hence Leia establishing the Resistance. The First Order literally obliterates the New Republic with Starkiller Base to destroy the Hosnian system (nerd alert)

The movie did a shit job of giving any context for all of that, but the two are separate entities. It's more likely they are laying the groundwork for how the Imperial remnants become the First Order.

The movie did a is shit

FTFY

I thought this episode was meh, but not great. The intro and outro were fine, but the bit in the middle suffered from a lot of things I think.

I don't mind the side story or the premise of it, but my main gripes were:

  • the music, especially in the wander around the city section, felt really generic and canned. Like video game loop music
  • There are not nearly enough people on Coruscant. Every place feels empty. Thats fine in some shots, but everything felt that way
  • The acting in the whole sequence felt wooden. No one really seemed to have any emotions about anything. The dialog really didn't help this

On the plus side, the duplication of the droid interview section worked really well. The whole idea of the reintegration program and how it is flawed works fine story-wise. The concept sketches in the credits showed a much better look/feel than the sets we got, costumes too. I think this is first time I can recall where the end credit images differed so significantly from what we got in the show.

Yeah, the dialogue is weak and the acting poor. But it's hard to show emotion when everyone is wearing a mask.

Here's a pretty crippling indictment of Season 3:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kMoaSzUijIQ

Reality has a mighty pimp hand.

Eh, take it with a grain of salt. Few things are more toxic than SW fans on youtube posting "explained" videos

Yeah, I clicked that link and rolled my eyes. And then remembered nobody hates Star Wars more than Star Wars fans.

Amen - my criteria is "did I enjoy this?" and it's usually a yes.

I loved TFA and TLJ (we shalt not speak of Ep 9). Love Mando, Rebels and thought Andor was the best thing I've seen on Disney+. Can't wait for Ahsoka and I'm super intrigued with Acolyte.

Okay, enjoyed the episode but have questions:

  1. After BK saves DD, she ass him if he saw anything alive in the water. She was very interested in this. Feels like foreshadowing, and/or context I'm missing?
  2. Are we supposed to know who this doctor is? He seems vaguely family but I don't recall.

Twitter me

1) She wanted to know if he saw the Mythosaur, which is the creature she saw when she rescued him at the end of the last episode. It could (likely will) have implications going forward because one of the legends says the person who can tame the Mythosaur will the leader of all the Mandalorian people. She already lost the Darksaber, which is another way to be the leader, that's why it might factor in later.

2) He's the doctor from season 1 that was leading the clone research whose Imperial remnant outfit was trying to capture Grogu.

Thanks! Regarding the Mythosaur - so BK saw the Mythosaur in the previous episode, but probably (literally) didn't believe her eyes?

Also, could they not come up with a better name than 'Mythosaur'? Reminds me of the rare metal in Avatar being called 'unobtainium' or whatever.

Twitter me

I think they intentionally left it a little vague. One hand, its like you said, maybe she wasn't quite sure she saw what she actually saw. On the other, she knows its the Mythosaur and wants to keep it to herself so she can use it to reclaim control of the Mandalorian people.

Episode 3 quick thoughts:

I love seeing TIE Interceptors and TIE Bombers.

I know this is a wild, science fiction universe with hyperspace travel and mind control but the idea of jumping off the back of a speeding train and landing safely on a soft stack of cloth made me audibly groan. There *has to be* a better way to write their exit from the train.

I think the train was slowing down as it approached the station, but yeah, it was pretty unrealistic.

I didn't like that whole sequence. So the "plan" was to hope the droids didn't come around to check tickets until late enough that you were by the first station and it was "slowing"...but still going fast as hell?

You do realize that Pershing was being set up from the start, right? Everything Elia did was to get the doctor caught so she could get him into that machine. Yeah, it was stupid because Pershing was gullible and needed to get that bit of thrill and overconfidence. This was a sting operation and the Coruscant police(?) were in on the whole thing.