Track Record of Virginia HS's 4 & 5 Stars

One of the "great debates" I've seen on TKP is the question of how much value 4 & 5 stars bring to the table. I've decided to compile a list of every 4 & 5 from the Commonwealth since 2002 (according to Rivals) to shed a little light on the subject. For obvious reasons, I didn't include players that were prepping at Fork Union or Hargrave.

Committed to Virginia Tech
Committed to UVA

2002: Kai Parham, Ahmad Brooks, Marcus Vick, Michael Johnson, Anthony Martinez, R.J. Coleman, Justin London, Jonathan Lewis, Thomas Clayton, Marcus Hamilton, Stefan Orange, Keenan Carter, Levi Brown (Total: 13)

2003: Phillip Brown, Chris Ellis, Vince Hall, Xavier Adibi, Matt Welsh (Total: 5)

2004: Chris Long, Olu Hall, Sean Glennon, Jerod Mayo, Kent Hicks, Eddie Royal (Total: 6)

2005: Macho Harris, Deveon Simmons, Stephen Friday, Vic Hall, Pat Shell, Elan Lewis, Todd Nolen (Total: 7)

2006: Percy Harvin, Brandon Minor, Vidal Hazelton, Damon McDaniel, Jarrell Miller, Chris Bell, Dedrick Epps, Alex Stadler, Sean Gottschalk, Brent Vinson, John Graves (Total: 11)

2007: Tyrod Taylor, Peter Lalich, Jamar Jackson, Terence Fells-Danzer, J'Courtney Williams, Bradley Starks, Chris Hill, Blake DeChristopher, Andrew Nuss, Jay Smith (Total: 10)

2008: E.J. Manuel, Ryan Williams, Mike Glennon, Quinton Coples, Josh Jenkins, Vinson Painter, Marcus Dowtin, Deion Walker, Kerry Boykins, Bobby Massie, Dyrell Roberts, D.J. Coles (Total: 12)

2009: Logan Thomas, Dominique Wallace, Tajh Boyd, David Wilson, Kevin Newsome, Bryn Renner, Morgan Moses, Jerod Askew, De'Antwan Williams, Quintin Hunter, Damien Thigpen, Tim Smith, Logan Heastie (Total: 13)

2010: Quinton Spain, Phillip Sims, J.R. Ferguson, Zack McCray, Justin Hunter, Travis Williams, Nick Dew, Nick Acree, Aramide Olaniyan, Jamel Turner, Mark Shuman (Total: 11)

2011: Curtis Grant, Landon Turner, Demetrious Nicholson, Travis Hughes, Dominique Terrell, Clifton Richardson, Ronny Vandyke, Corey Marshall (Total: 8)

2012: J.C. Coleman, Alex Carter, Kwontie Moore, Eli Harold, Joel Caleb, Deon Clarke, Ken Ekanem, Trey Edmunds, Korren Kirven, Win Homer (Total: 10)

2013: Taquan Mizzel, Derrick Green, Christian Hackenberg, Jonathan Allen, Wyatt Teller, Ryan Burns, E.J. Levenberry Jr., Bucky Hodges, Holland Fisher, Doug Randolph, Tim Harris, Matt Rolin (Total: 12)

2014: Da'Shawn Hand, Quin Blanding, Andrew Brown, Derrick Nnadi, Alec Eberle, Jalyn Holmes, Caleb Henderson, Jamil Kamara, Steven Moss, Ricky Walker, Raymond Minor, C.J. Reavis, Marshawn Williams (Total: 13)

2015: Josh Sweat, Javoni Simmons, Clelin Ferrell, Ricky DeBerry, Garrett Taylor, Matthew Burrell Jr., Austin Clark, Tim Settle, Darvin Taylor II, Jaason Lewis (Total: 10)