OT: Cheese on Apple Pie (again)

By: ShagVT on September 6, 2017, 2:18 PM | 5 comments

So we had this discussion a couple of months ago, debating the virtues of cheese on apple pie: http://www.thekeyplay.com/content/2017/july/14/ot-cheese-apple-pie

At long last I finally had the chance to try this ... a nice warm slice of apple pie, a nice slice of extra sharp cheddar on top, given time to melt. The rest of the family went with whipped cream and stared at me like you might look at roadkill in front of your house.

I have to say I was thoroughly unimpressed. It wasn't bad ... but honestly, the sweetness of the apples and the flavor of the cinnamon totally overpowered any cheese flavor. One of my girls suggested that maybe I was doing it wrong and suggested adding a second slice of cheese. I figured "why not?" Still utterly unimpressed.

Why would anybody do this to pie when vanilla ice cream or whipped cream are available?

Forums: 
Off Topic
DISCLAIMER: Forum topics may not have been written or edited by The Key Play staff.

Comments

BetaEta576's picture BetaEta576 | 8 years 10 months #

Glad that's settled. Now, imagine how unimpressed you would have been if your family had had cake instead of pie

french60wasp's picture french60wasp
| 8 years 10 months #

Cheese on pie? On a French film review day?

via GIPHY

Five star get after it 100 percent Juice Key-Playing. MAN

ShagVT's picture ShagVT | 8 years 10 months # ^

Too Druck to Funk's picture Too Druck to Funk | 8 years 10 months #

I just don't understand why we're even debating this.

It was good enough for Travis Bickle, and he turned out just fine.

the numbers don’t lie and they spell disaster

Leonard's picture Leonard | 8 years 10 months #

I've tried this before, because I thought it would be cool to say that I eat my apple pie with a slice of cheddar.

I've since learned that those who eat their apple pie with a a scoop of vanilla are the coolest motherfuckers going.

Leonard. Duh.