Ask TKP: how would you rate the top 10 based on resumes alone?

1. Bama. 5 P5 wins - none ranked
2. PSU. 5 P5 wins- none ranked
3. UGA. 5 P5 wins - one ranked 13
4. TCU. 5 P5 wins - one ranked 10th, one ranked 23rd
5. Whisky. 3 P5 wins - none ranked
6. OHio St 4 P5 wins - loss to one ranked 9th
7. Klemp. 5 P5 wins - one ranked 14, one ranked 21, unranked loss
8. Da U. 3 P5 wins, none ranked
9. Okay. 3 P5 wins - one ranked 6, one unranked loss
10. Okay s. 3 P5 wins - loss to one ranked 4
10.5 USCw. 5 P5 wins - one ranked 22, loss to one ranked 15

Who's ranking is most suspect? Who is not getting enough credit?

Seems the whole BIG is over-rated, with no decent wins. Little 12 is only beating themselves. Lot of untested teams.

Seems like most of the teams are still ranked more by reputation than performance, but based on resume alone, I'd have TCU, UGA, Bama, PSU, Wisky, da U, Okay St, Klempson, OKay, OSU, USCw.

DISCLAIMER: Forum topics may not have been written or edited by The Key Play staff.

Comments

PSU and Miami are the most suspect. Hard to say anyone in the top 10 is not getting enough credit though.

I have no idea why my username is VT_Warthog.

Arkansas blew a 24-0 lead in the Belk Bowl.

To discredit Ohio State I guarantee would be your own undoing. Easy as it seems

Whisky, USC and Miami are all gonna fall.

Klempson is gonna fall without Bryant

...Miami are all gonna fall...

Nobody seems to be any good yet, Wisconsin, PSU, and Miami have had zero actual tests but move up by attrition.

I'd say UGA and TCU probably have the best wins, but Alabama has wins in all the best ways.

Clemson, OK, OKSt and OhioState all have blemishes of wildly differing severity but all appear to be pretty strong.

I really think USCw is pretty average this year, with any luck ND will put them back in their place this weekend

Georgia has looked pretty damn good this year. Bama is bama.

I want to like Penn State because I think Saquon Barkley is amazing, but I've yet to see anything out of them that amazes me.

No one else really jumps out as being substantially better than anyone else.

Clemson has the better resume because they beat that tough VT squad at home.

If you play it, they will win.

"How the ass pocket will be used, I do not know. Alls I know is, the ass pocket will be used." -The BoD

Big10 love fest is real. Ohio State hasn't played anybody outside of Oklahoma. How'd that go? Penn St almost laid an egg against Iowa. Wisconsin hasn't played anyone. And yet they get a lot of attention. I can only hope Michigan takes care of business tonight, but that sounds so dirty when you are married to a buckeye.

TKPhi Damn Proud
BSME 2009

1. Virginia Tech
2. Virginia Tech
3. Virginia Tech
4. Virginia Tech
5. Virginia Tech
6. Virginia Tech
7. Virginia Tech
8. Virginia Tech
9. Virginia Tech
10. Virginia Tech

The taste is so divine
A chemical come alive
Welcome to your vice
Good luck with life
'Cause you can't
You can't
You can't kill me that easily

hype about calling Oklahoma and Ok St "Okay' and "Okay St" from now on

I just sit on my couch and b*tch. - HokieChemE2016