Recent Comments

The argument that a 1 loss Bama is still better than most every team in the country is extremely valid. And if you truly want to see who the best team in the nation is you can't exclude them from a tournament so large just because they lost their conference championship game.

What about those times they don't even PLAY in their championship game? They allegedly won a goddamned NATIONAL CHAMPIONSHIP by beating LSU after they'd already LOST to LSU and had the benefit of having Georgia (I think it was>) soften them up first. They didn't play for the SEC title this year either and if Mizzou had won, there'd be a contingent of whiney pantywastes (a great many of whom work for SECSPN) screaming that Bama should be the number 2 team playing FSU for the national championship.

I really don't see how the offense as a whole got worse. Read French's articles. We're seeing better technique, better body position, better gameplanning (for the most part, although the bar was set pretty low there) and play design. The failures of this year's offense were mostly related to talent, which can be fixed with recruiting, and execution, which can be fixed with more than 8 months' experience in a particular system.

I guess the question is how good are those returning starters? If they aren't good enough, more waiting for Loeffler while we suffer through another offensive season like this?

I applaud your optimism, but the concerns about Loeffler aren't unfounded.

I look at 3 plays in particular in the first half of the LOLUVA game and grin. I suspect there are some interesting things afoot.

Next year will be fun. We'll lean on our defense a lot next year but, the playbook will open some with the Fr/so having a year of learning them under their belt.

I suspect we'll start the year with Leal because he's had the playbook for a year and the other guys haven't. I expect a redshirt QB to learn the offense next year and mature and we come out swinging with that QB in 2015 along with the Juniors and seniors in the rest of the offense that grew up with the improved skill coaching and know the playbook.

I am excited for 2014 and 2015.
The glass is 3/4 full. I'm making my donations and plotting so I have the best seats possible for 2015-16.

Lane Stadium 50 yd line will be the best seats in college football 2015-16.

NCAA to NFL does not parallel. NFL is designed for a playoff system. There is one league of 32 teams is nothing like the 120 odd team in Div 1 football with major and minor conferences of mostly 12 teams each, plus independents. You cannot have a large playoff like NFL. It just will not work. Only way to make it remotely "fair" is to do March Madness style that keeps getting bigger and bigger, and that's never gonna happen.

Or one might point out that he inherited Logan Thomas, statistically the best QB to ever play at Virginia Tech, and he made the offense worse.

Guys maybe this is what we needed. Play a ranked and very respected team in UCLA... BUT NOT IN A BCS bowl. Maybe the guys will come in relaxed with no pressure and play. There's no record/ media build up that we shouldn't be at this game or ohh the Chokies are 1-8 or whatever in BCS bowls they suck.. Its just a game to go and play.

Yes it hurt to call my beloved Hokies the C word but its what I heard all last year and this year.

9. That's how many starters we get back next year (drop it to 8 if you want to consider DJ). Plus, we get our best TE back from injury, and you already saw how much Lefty likes to use the TE, even with a true freshman. I think this year would have gone differently if Loeffler had a TE he knew he could trust all year long. The amount of youth on this offense and the influx of talent coming in next year should be reasons for optimism. It's not like we went 8-4 with a bunch of NFL-bound seniors. *cough* UNC *cough*.

Some teams get better as the season goes on. It happens int he NFL all the time. Look at the Eagles this year, they started out atrocious and now found their way and have a chance to win the NFC East. Under your logic they shouldn't go to the playoff because another team might have 1 more win that didn't qualify for the playoff. (I know this is Granny Smith to Golden Delicious, but it still has parallels).

If we would be able to beat FSU because Winston went down to a season ending injury, FSU probably wouldn't fare as well in a playoff. VT would deserve their spot unless maybe there was a undefeated mid major that won their conference, but you're against that too.

I disagree quite a bit with this. "I saw nothing in his first year..." Well, I saw quite a bit. I saw intelligent design in the passing game, a gameplan that used certain plays and formations to set up other plays, etc. He did what he needed to do to win, and a good deal of the time he was pretty successful. Look what he had to work with: Newsome's Oline (I could end the discussion here, but for funsies, I'll continue). Inexperienced (to put it lightly) or fat/hurt receivers, inexperienced running backs and a QB in need of a complete mechanical overhaul (when a player says he's learned more in 3 months than in the previous 4 years, that's a big problem). Yes, there will always be playcalls that every coordinator wishes he had back. That's football. Just seems like if a play is unsuccessful, the fanbase tries their best to pin it on Lefty. Either he went too conservative and should have opened the playbook up more, or he got too cute and should have stuck with the team's identity. For a guy with so much inexperience, a lack of overall talent and the garbage of the previous coaching staff to deal with, I think he did a pretty darn good job. This year, it was his job to extinguish the dumpster fire and at the same time find ways to win. 8 times out of 12, he did that. Now, it's his job to actually build his own offense. I say give him a year or two more before you start calling for his head and we repeat this process all over again.

Expect film breakdowns. This was just an early look. There's still 3 weeks until the game. I don't know of a comparable website.

That's why I'm proposing to draw a line in the sand. Don't put duct tape on what we have now. Revamp the entire system and layout. Six conferences. 16 Teams apiece. 96 teams. All monies split among them. If there was an 8 team playoff, the 6 winners would be in plus 2 at-large. The money division become easy among the conferences.

Each SEC school is receiving $10-14mil per year just on the reg season contract. Yes, OleMiss is getting some crumbs from the bowl games that they AREN'T playing in, but it's not a make-or-break amount. $1mil? maybe. Again, revamping the entire system, they won't have to worry about how much they may or may not be getting from the bowls. And won't have to make a decision on how mush they might lose to go play in the Pin Stripe Bowl in a baseball stadium in New York over the Holidays.

And you can't tell me that a sponsor wouldn't pay $5mil to advertise in the national semi-final game versus $1mil apiece in 5 minor bowl games?

Yes, I completely agree. Malzahn found a great quarterback who could consistently make reads in the running and passing game. In addition to that, he's an exceptional athlete with 4.3 speed. He is a huge part of Auburn's success this year.

We desperately need to find a quarterback of that caliber to turn around our offense. Logan was good, but wildly inconsistent both mechanically and when making reads in the running and passing game. Of course, it's not all his fault, and he should've gotten a lot more help from the OLine, running backs, playcalling, etc, to cover up his weaknesses. But regardless, if you look at the top teams every season, almost all of them have a consistent playmaker at qb.

I could see, especially since it's such a debateable topic in the NFL, player safety being the biggest discussion point into doing a 16 team playoff. You're talking about adding 4 games against stellar opponents at the end of a season.

Counting conference championship games, you're talking 17 games per year. Now, that is less than what NFL players play in a full season counting the super bowl, but I could see where this discussion would come up.

Myles Jack... how is it that he's just a freshman? I'd hate to be any Pac-12 team playing against him in the next couple of years...

An 8 team totally waters it down, because all you're going to have to do is win your conference. Sure conference games take on more importance, but non-con certainly lose it. And just take this year, for example - suppose Duke lost to UNC and we got to go to the ACC Championship game. And then, imagine we upset FSU (maybe Winston breaks his hand on Manbearpig or something). So now, this VT team that has lost 4 games this year (including games to Duke and UMD!) and got blasted by Bama in the opener is in the playoff. Those four losses - nbd. Just win your conference, even if it's by the skin of your teeth, and you're in. Boo.

Thanks BCO. I slipped up at the end, but I hope to see everyone in the bowl pick'em.

the point is that 1 million dollars to an Idaho is a bucket full, not a drop, because they get next to nothing from networks. And had we followed what you are saying it would had been exceedingly difficult for Frank to climb the Hokies out of obscurity and into a major conference. we never would have gotten the money to build on.

Most recently Boise and Utah got this chance. Utah won the lottery and Boise got the shaft. This is why Peterson left.

Pages