Recent Comments

I keep hearing how Herman is a great recruiter and Fuente isn't, but lets look at a few things.

-First just look at the differences in what each coach was walking into in terms of a program between Memphis and Houston. Houston's last 4 coaches have been Art Briles, Kevin Sumlin, Tony Levine, and Tom Herman. Houston wasn't the dumpster fire that Memphis was when Herman took over. Last 4 coaches at Memphis were Rip Scherer, Tommy West, Larry Porter, and Justin Fuente. Quite a difference in where these two programs were coming from.

-Previously Herman was at Ohio State working for Urban Meyer. In that situation how could he NOT bring in top recruits? It isn't hard to bring in top talent to a place like Ohio State as evidenced by the QB situation they currently have.

-This is Herman's 1st full season at Houston and in looking at '15 recruiting class Houston brought in 1 four star, 6 three star, and the rest were below three star recruits. The '16 class has 1 five star, 2 four stars, 12 three stars with the rest ranked below three stars. Important to note that the five star recruit is from Houston, Tx and out of the 18 commits 15 are from the state of Texas. I don't think many would argue against Texas having a much bigger talent pool than the state of Tennessee.

-Memphis' last two recruiting classes have been 3 stars and under, but again this program was in a completely different state than Houston was and Houston has a much better talent pool to choose from being in Texas.

I'm not trying to say that Herman isn't a great coach because he IS a great coach as evidenced by the product he has put on the field this year, and the difference between OSU's offense last year to this year. However, I would argue that had Fuente came into the same situation the results would have been very similar if not the same. If Herman went to Memphis four years ago I can't see him instantly bringing in 4 and 5 star guys right off the bat to that program and winning 10-11 games his first year. I think if we get either of these guys its a GREAT hire for us and both will have success. IMO looking at the whole picture (state of program, location etc.) puts both of these guys closer together vs one being a lot better than the other.

The same could be said about Houston. Not many people are going to choose them over Texas, aTm, Baylor, TCU, Oklahoma, LSU, Bama, etc. Herman has the 5 star, #2 DT in the nation committed to Houston right now, and two other 4-stars. And a 4-star RB from last year's class. Fuente has never gotten higher than a 3-star in his tenure at Memphis.

Now, the argument could be made that Houston has the benefit of being in much better recruiting grounds (TX) than Memphis. Still, when you have that many Power 5 schools in TX, OK, and nearby in the SEC, it definitely says something about Herman's efforts there.

In fine with Herman, Fuente, or Mullen. LSU looks to be opening up as I saw on the ESPN ticker that Les Miles suggested that Saturday would be his last game. If that happens it will be interesting to see what happens there.

Also, I'm not sure where everyone gets this trepidation with Fuente and recruiting. He has been at Memphis for a few years and had them in the top 15 from the lower depth is div-1 football. Memphis isn't a big name school and not a power five school so recruiting is gonna be hard especially when you are trying to recruit the same areas as the SEC. Not many people are gonna forego the sec for Memphis or another pwr5 school. He has a glass ceiling in that respect. So I don't think his recruiting is necessarily poor.

On Herman we don't know how is recruiting is. I'm sure it's good but he was also recruiting for OSU which sort of sells itself. His ability isn't in question as you see what he has at Houston and how OSU looks without him. However Houston wasn't horrible before him. They were still putting together winning seasons and were a decent team. So how much is him and how much is why he walked into. If he walked into fuente's situation in Memphis would he have been able to have the same success. Plus he is only in year one of being a HC where Fuente is a few years in.

So there are pros and cons to argue for both. I think both would be awesome hires. If Memphis is a one loss team and Houston has 3 do we think Fuente is the hot name??

Pages