Recent Comments

I wish I could give you more legs for the research. However, my opinion hasn't changed. The defender targeted the head and neck of a defenseless player. I would consider him defenseless because he hadn't established himself as a runner yet. Similarly, if he had lost the ball, I think it would have been ruled an incomplete pass rather than a fumble.

If I'm in charge of making the rule, I would have a much more severe definition of targeting and defenseless. But if I was officiating that play under the current rules and emphasis, I'd make the same ruling.

The fact that you and I interpret it differently is proof that the rule sucks as written.

The FBI loves to hire lawyers especially ones that have a bachelors or other degree level in another field, accounting, computer science, even know a guy who majored in forestry and then went to law school then FBI.

I mean I'll put it this way...I was advising a 17-year-old girl last year about attending either UVa or Virginia Tech. She really wanted to go to vet school. I was trying to convince her to go to Virginia Tech because of A) the strength of the agricultural department and B) We actually have a vet school. She responded back "Well, you can major in anything you want to and go to vet school afterwards."

After a few weeks, she finally decided to attend VT over UVa but it took a lot of convincing that actually majoring in a subject field that will relate to your future endeavors is a smart idea. If Tino wants to go become an FBI agent or something to that effect, going to UMD and majoring in criminal justice isn't a bad way to go.

I always found it laughable that we were so high on him (Ford) -- we only got him because we got turned down by Cornwell, Park and Rudolph (if my memory serves me correctly).

It's like you said, every fanbase does this with every new recruit.

Let the boys compete and then I'll cheer for whoever wins the job.

He needs to come back to college. His type of football doesn't work in the NFL. He relies on his players being faster and more conditioned than his opponents and that doesn't happen in the NFL. He also seems to rub his players the wrong way too.

Tell me about it. I'd love to get a shot at officiating big-time college football, but the overall quality of officials coupled with the low turnover rate isn't exactly encouraging.

Yeah they would. Which makes more sense to me than an unsportsmanlike 15 yarder. It's going to be incredibly difficult to get a kid to stop playing after his helmet comes off. Like I said, I completely understand its for player safety and all and it makes sense in principle but incredibly difficult to ask a kid to stop mid-play when its their natural instinct to keep going.

edit: Art Briles just made my point for me.

Happily, it was done about as perfectly as it could have been. The field judge had a close call on a hit that was high and hard - when in doubt, it is a foul. So we've got a flag down and we're gonna talk about it. Ok, now we're going up to the replay booth. Booth says it was a clean hit, no foul, carry on.

In a perfect world, it would have been flagged, but that's really tricky for the umpire to see. Even if that had been called, Oakman would have offset that foul with his own foul. No matter what, if your helmet comes off and you're not already in the act of tackling someone, you have to stop playing.

Pages