Recent Comments
I don't disagree with the assertion that we were a loser on NSD. We had 3 studs that we had a good chance to bring in and lost all three. That doesn't mean we had a bad recruiting class, are on a downward spiral, etc. I'm okay with that as an honest assessment.
My issue with the article is that most of the "winners" were based on a team's overall class and not who they swooped up on NSD. Mentioning Brown for loluva is pointless because he's already been enrolled. I think the author wrote the losers before the winners, forgetting what the real topic was in the meantime.
Must have skipped over the bit about Searels before, but I'll say this: It is impossible for him to be anything less than a gigantic step up from Newsome. He's at least coming into a situation where the guys in the program have had a year of legitimate, competent fundamentals coaching and the new guys coming in should be athletic upgrades over most of the current OL in the program.
Also if I got any of the data wrong on the previous or current recruits/* rankings, feel free to correct me, not sure it's 100% accurate.
Kinda related, but then kind of not related: fact I heard today on Mike and Mike and Mike and Mike.
Every single 5* recruit that has signed with Alabama under Saban has gone on to be a 1st round draft pick in the NFL. 5 star guys matter.
In reference to your topic, I think we'll finally see some raw athleticism come out on the offense side of the ball. Hopefully we have a run game, seeing how we signed two highly recruited running backs. I'm on the side that the wheels are rolling in the right direction.
From the sound of it, might do him some good to be at the JC for a year...
General thought is that we'll start seeing significant improvement in the next 2-3 years.
Boo Hoo, my editor told me to write about winners and losers. Get back to us with another article in 2016. I like our chances with improved coaching, a better offensive scheme, and a 'kick-ass' attitude.
i would argue many 4 stars are just as good as a 5 star for the college game. 5 stars may just have what it takes to be more "League" ready. i believe it was rivals who actually disclosed that their ratings had less to do with how a player projected at the collegiate level and more to do with their NFL prospects.
now, i recognize that a kid who is NFL material will be a great college player, too, but there are plenty of GREAT college football players who may never even get a shot at the NFL, let alone be a top draft pick.
i think the whole reason they shifted from a 4 star system and added the 5th star was basically to differentiate between the 25-35 kids they thought had a legit shot to be top NFL draft picks in 3-5 years and those who would be great for college, but maybe not project to the NFL just yet as an 18 year old.
I hope he underestimates how fast Dadi is...
He had to have faxed one first, right? So, for his sake, I hope he didn't send the LOI to the junior college before the others.
I'm just glad CBS hasn't traded Jim Nantz for Joe Buck, because a Buck/Simms combo would just be horrible.
The issue is brokering. NCAA limits the contacts college coaches can have with recruits. Apparently no limit on college coaches talking to "others" and recruits talking to those same "others". 7o7 and similar organizations are trying to exploit loopholes by using "others" to make unlimited contacts with recruits. As long as the colleges aren't paying the others (like Oregon did) there does not seem to be a technical violation. Uva may be using some other form of compensation to these organizations or maybe not. It is a gray area. I'm not sure I like these pay for play organizations. Both pros and cons (take that any way you want). They are not just in football. Ever heard of soccer travelling teams? For those that can afford it, it is a way to expose your kids to high level of competition. I think CFB comes from a background where he believes in underdogs and people that do things on their own.
|
12 years 5 months
# | Hokies one of 3 biggest losers of National Signing Day per CollegeFootballTalk Don't forget people. Our favorite 7 on 7 coaches son Corwin Cutler is coming out of FUMA and going to UVA.
edit: too many ises
Looking at this past year's 13 NFL Network games, it's barely above 50% divisional. Ironically, the Bills and Browns played each other on one of those games.
Has their ever been a horse on a treadmill effect shirt? It's grown to be a pretty big cult following.
(Assuming they should just buy all the TKP shirts)
Man, I hope he wins the starting job.
You missed the point. There wa a comparison of MD retaining guys instate and VT retaining guys instate.
It's a poor comparison. And completely irrelevant.
Fair enough, I guess I was comparing travel time with a stop or two but that would add a half an hour to all my other distances. Plus I drive slow :-)
Anyway, my point is, there isn't anywhere in the state that is much further away from Blacksburg than the 757 right?
Don't think so but the last I heard was that if he got any bigger, they'd need to start using an escalator to conduct the interview face to face. Right now a ladder works just fine.
Has he said in interviews how tall he is lately?
Not sure but we have been slowly climbing up his list ever since Stroman committed to Tech.
For class ranking their point system is out of proportion. They give 200 points for a 5*, 120 for a 4, 40 for 3. A 5* is good but I don't think there is that much difference between a 5 and a 4 or 3. Is a 5* five times better than a 3*?
Well, his daughter might be the devil.......
having not followed 2015 recruiting yet at all...how are our chances looking with Settle? Way too early? Are we in his top 3?

QB: Brandon Motley (wishful thinking if he is good enough), Andrew Ford (should RS will start following year)
RB: Trey Edmunds, Marshawn Williams, J.C. Coleman, (RS Shai to heal injury)
FB: Sam Rogers, Jerome Wright
TE: Ryan Malleck, Kalvin Cline, Bucky Hodges, (RS Chris Durkin but put him with these guys)
Flanker: Demetri Knowles, Isaiah Ford, Jaylen Bradshaw
Split End: Joshua Stanford, Kendrick Holland
Slot: Willie Byrn, Cam Phillips
LT: Jon McLaughlin, Augie Conte
LG: Jake Goins, Alston Smith,
C: Calib Farris, David Wang
RG: David Wang, Kyle Chung, Baraxton Pfaff
RT: Laurance Gibson, Wyatt Teller